Support for Clinical Trials at NIMH
In 2014, NIH revised its definition of a clinical trial (see NOT-OD-15-015 ) and in 2015, launched a multi-faceted effort to enhance its stewardship over clinical trials (see NIH webpage on Clinical Trial Requirements for Grants and Contracts ). All applicants conducting research on human subjects are encouraged to carefully review this webpage to better understand the definition of a clinical trial, new requirements for clinical trial research, and NIH strategies for implementation. Given the current NIH definition of clinical trials, some investigators are discovering that their human subjects research is now considered to fall under the NIH definition of a clinical trial and is subject to the NIH clinical trial requirements. This includes ‘Basic Experimental Studies with Humans’ (abbreviated BESH) which are studies that are defined as both “basic science research” and “NIH-defined Clinical Trials” (see below for more information).
NIH requires that all applications involving one or more independent clinical trials be submitted through a notice of funding opportunity (NOFO or "funding opportunity") specifically designated as ‘Clinical Trial Required,’ ‘Clinical Trial Optional,’ or ‘Basic Experimental Studies with Humans.’ The content below provides an overview of how the NIMH approaches its clinical trial portfolio and provides links to relevant NIMH funding opportunities that support clinical trial research. General inquiries regarding NIMH clinical trials and/or the clinical trial funding opportunities may be submitted to NIMHClinicalTrials@mail.nih.gov.
NIH definition of a clinical trial
NIH defines a clinical trial as “A research study in which one or more human subjects are prospectively assigned to one or more interventions (which may include placebo or other control) to evaluate the effects of those interventions on health-related biomedical or behavioral outcomes” (NOT-OD-15-015 ). Go to NIH’s Definition of a Clinical Trial webpage to learn more and to find out if your study meets the NIH definition of a clinical trial.
NIMH funding opportunities to address the safety, efficacy, and effectiveness of preventive, therapeutic, and services interventions
NIMH solicits clinical trial applications through a series of funding opportunities that cover the intervention development pipeline, from first-in-human, early testing of new interventions, confirmatory efficacy trials, through to effectiveness trials. If the goal of the clinical trial application is to establish the safety, clinical efficacy, effectiveness, clinical management and/or implementation of preventive, therapeutic, or therapeutic interventions, the application must be submitted in response to one of the funding opportunities as outlined in the Clinical Trial Pipeline - Phase of Intervention Development below. Applications that involve clinical trials to establish safety, clinical efficacy, effectiveness, clinical management and/or implementation of interventions should NOT be submitted under the NIH Parent funding opportunity for clinical trials and, if done so, will be returned without review.
NIMH requires an experimental therapeutics approach (see Clinical trials applicant FAQs, Q3) for the development and testing of therapeutic, preventive, and services interventions, in which the studies evaluate not only the clinical effect of the intervention, but also generate information about the mechanisms underlying a disorder or an intervention response. Studies proposed under these funding opportunities must clearly identify a target or mediator of the intervention being tested. A positive result will require that an intervention improves clinical outcomes and has a demonstrable effect on a target, such as a neural pathway, a key cognitive operation, interpersonal or contextual factor that is hypothesized to mediate the intervention’s effect, etc.
The NIMH funding opportunities for therapeutic, preventive, and services interventions support a wide range of intervention modalities: cognitive, behavioral, and other psychosocial approaches, psychopharmacological interventions, and interventions utilizing direct brain modulation/stimulation. The choice of targets, measures, and clinical endpoints will vary with the intervention modality. Applicants should carefully read the NOFO to which they are responding and the Clinical trials applicant FAQs for more detail on the expectations for specific intervention modalities. Applicants are strongly encouraged to contact a Scientific/Research Contact listed at the end of the relevant funding opportunity to discuss the NOFO and NIMH priorities.
First in Human | Exploratory Experimental Therapeutics | Confirmatory Efficacy | Effectiveness (Prevention, Treatment, Services) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
First in Human and Early Stage Clinical Trials of Novel Investigational Drugs or Devices for Psychiatric Disorders (U01 - Clinical Trial Required ) | Pilot Effectiveness Trials for Treatment, Preventive and Services Interventions (R34 - Clinical Trial Required ) | ||||||
Early Stage Testing of Pharmacologic or Device-based Interventions for the Treatment of Mental Disorders (R61/R33 - Clinical Trial Required ) and (R33 - Clinical Trial Required )* | Clinical Trials to Test the Effectiveness of Treatment, Preventive, and Services Interventions (R01 Clinical Trial Required ) or (Collaborative R01 - Clinical Trial Required ) | ||||||
Development of Psychosocial Therapeutic and Preventive Interventions for Mental Disorders (R61/R33- Clinical Trial Required ) and (R33 Clinical Trial Required ) | Confirmatory Efficacy Clinical Trials of Non-Pharmacological Interventions for Mental Disorders (R01 Clinical Trial Required ) |
Limited NIMH participation on parent research grant NOFOs are to accommodate mechanistic clinical trials
NIMH utilizes the NIH Parent R01 Clinical Trial Required , the NIH Parent R21 Clinical Trial Required , the NIH Parent R01 Basic Experimental Studies with Humans , and the NIH Parent R21 Basic Experimental Studies with Humans to accept only “mechanistic” clinical trial applications (see below for descriptors of “mechanistic” clinical trials).
The Basic Experimental Studies with Humans (BESH) funding opportunities are parent notices for studies that fall within the NIH definition of a clinical trial and also meet the definition of basic research, as described in NIH Guide Notice NOT-OD-19-024 . Applicants proposing Basic Experimental Studies with Humans (BESH) are required to complete the full Human Subjects and Clinical Trial Information in the application form and to register and report results.
NIMH support of mechanistic clinical trials: NIH defines a mechanistic clinical trial as a study “designed to understand a biological or behavioral process, the pathophysiology of a disease, or the mechanism of action of an intervention.” NIMH supports mechanistic clinical trials that focus on biomarker studies that may provide information about physiological function, target engagement of therapeutics, and/or the impact of therapeutic responses. These types of studies do not have as a primary aim to establish the efficacy or effectiveness of the intervention.
NIMH considers two major categories of mechanistic trials (though there may be others):
- Mechanistic clinical trials using an intervention of known efficacy. These clinical trials utilize an efficacious intervention to investigate the pathophysiology, and/or psychopathology of mental disorders or the mechanisms of therapeutic responses; and to advance biomarkers of basic neurobiological processes. In such studies: (1) the primary aims do not involve establishing efficacy/effectiveness, and (2) the intervention chosen has already been demonstrated to have efficacy. These trials must be submitted under the NIH Parent R01 Clinical Trial Required or the NIH Parent R21 Clinical Trial Required
- Mechanistic clinical trials utilizing an experimental manipulation: These studies utilize experimental manipulation and are primarily focused on understanding brain function in healthy individuals or those with disorders by measuring responses to the experimental manipulation. Most of these mechanistic studies are expected to be responsive to the BESH funding opportunities (described above) since they are not intended to inform on the improvement of the health status of the individual or a group of individuals either by better understanding the mechanism of action of an intervention or a measurable improvement in health.
See the “Consolidated Notice on NIMH Clinical Trials Policies,” NOT-MH-20-105 , for a summary of NIMH’s polices on support for mechanistic and other clinical trials.
Selected other clinical trial funding opportunities
NIMH also participates on selected funding opportunities that seek or allow clinical trial applications, some of which include other grant mechanisms than noted above. Applications submitted to NIMH via these funding opportunities are expected to comport with NIMH’s experimental therapeutics approach.
These funding opportunities include:
- Announcements from other NIH Institutes or Centers (on which NIMH participates)
- Career (K) funding opportunities that accept independent clinical trials or Basic Experimental Studies with Humans (on which NIMH participates; see NIMH guidance for K applicants proposing Clinical Trials)
- Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) and Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) funding opportunities
A current listing of these funding opportunities can be found on the NIMH Funding Opportunities & Announcements webpage.
Additional resources for applicants
- Visit the National Database for Clinical Trials (NDCT).
- Visit the Clinical Research page for links to policies governing human subjects research safety and monitoring.
- View the Webinar: PHS Human Subjects and Clinical Trials Information Form Walk-through .
- Visit the NIH/NIMH Therapeutics Discovery Research page for links to NIMH programs and resources related to therapeutic discovery and development, as well as complementary programs available through broader NIH efforts.
Selected publications
- Gordon J. NIMH Director’s Messages: An Experimental Therapeutic Approach to Psychosocial Interventions. National Institute of Mental Health. March 20, 2017.
- Gogtay N and Insel T. NIMH Clinical Trials: Portfolio, Progress to Date, and the Road ForwardNational Institute of Mental Health. 2015.
- Insel TR and Gogtay N. National Institute of Mental Health Clinical Trials: New Opportunities, New Expectations. JAMA Psychiatry . 2014 May 7.
- Insel TR. A New Approach to Clinical Trials. National Institute of Mental Health. February 27, 2014.
Published guide notices
- NOT-MH-19-006 (December 21, 2018) - NIMH Acceptance of Clinical Trial Applications under the Parent R01 and R21 Clinical Trial Required, or Basic Experimental Studies Involving Humans (BESH) Announcements is Limited to Mechanistic Clinical Trials
- NOT-MH-17-044 (August 17, 2017) - Notice of NIMH's Interest in Pediatric Pharmacologic Trials in Autism Spectrum Disorders, directed at testing selective GABAergic agents
- NOT-MH-17-039 (July 24, 2017) - Notice of NIMH's Interest to Highlight High-Priority Pediatric Pharmacologic Trial Research Areas
- NOT-MH-15-012 (March 17, 2015) - Data Sharing Expectations for Clinical Research Funded by NIMH
- NOT-MH-15-009 (January 16, 2015) - Notice Announcing Data Harmonization for NIMH Human Subjects Research via the PhenX Toolkit
- NOT-MH-14-015 (June 12, 2014) - Data Sharing Expectations for NIMH-funded Clinical Trials
- NOT-MH-14-004 (January 15, 2014) - Enhancing the Reliability of NIMH-Supported Research through Rigorous Study Design and Reporting
Clinical trials applicant FAQs
Morgan P et al. Can the flow of medicines be improved? Fundamental pharmacokinetic and pharmacological principles toward improving Phase II survival. Drug Discov Today. 2012 May; 17(9-10):419-424. PMID: 22227532